The Truth About SAT/ACT Scores: Are They Still Important?
The role of standardized testing in college admissions has undergone significant changes in recent years, leaving many students and parents wondering whether SAT and ACT scores still matter. With some colleges maintaining test-optional policies and others returning to requiring standardized test scores, the answer isn’t as straightforward as it once was. Here’s a closer look at the current landscape and how to approach standardized testing in today’s admissions process.
What Are Test-Optional Policies?
Test-optional policies allow students to decide whether to submit SAT or ACT scores (and, in some cases, AP scores) as part of their college application. These policies gained momentum during the COVID-19 pandemic, as testing centers closed and students faced disruptions.
Test-Optional: Students can choose to submit scores if they believe the scores will strengthen their application. Some also have No Harm policies, guaranteeing that there will be no negative impact if an applicant elects to withhold test scores.
Test-Blind: Schools that are test-blind do not consider standardized test scores at all, even if submitted.
Do SAT/ACT Scores Still Matter?
While the rise of test-optional policies has reduced the emphasis on standardized tests for some colleges, these scores can still play an important role in the admissions process, depending on the school and the applicant.
When They Matter:
Competitive Schools: At highly selective institutions, strong scores can still be a differentiating factor.
Scholarship Opportunities: Some merit-based scholarships require SAT or ACT scores for eligibility.
Supplemental Strength: If a student’s GPA or class rank is on the lower side, high test scores can help balance their application.
When They Don’t:
Test-Optional Schools: For students with strong GPAs and extracurricular achievements, skipping the test can reduce stress without hurting their chances.
Test-Blind Schools: At these schools, scores are irrelevant.
How to Decide Whether to Submit Scores
Students should weigh the pros and cons of submitting test scores based on their individual circumstances and the requirements of their target schools.
Check School Policies: Research each college’s stance on standardized testing. Many schools have detailed FAQs about how they consider scores.
Evaluate Your Scores: Compare your scores to the middle 50% range of admitted students at your target schools.
Consider Your Strengths: If your academic record, essays, and extracurriculars are strong, you may not need to rely on test scores to stand out.
Preparing for the SAT/ACT
If you decide to take the SAT or ACT, preparation is key. Here are some tips for success:
Start Early: Begin preparing at least 3-6 months before your test date to build confidence and familiarity with the format.
Take Practice Tests: Simulated tests help identify areas of weakness and improve time management.
Focus on Weak Areas: Target your studying to the sections where you need the most improvement.
Enlist a Professional’s Help: 1:1 test prep support can provide a meaningful boost to your confidence, comprehension, and (ultimately) test score.
Life Beyond Testing
For students who choose not to submit test scores, it’s essential to focus on other parts of the application:
Essays: Craft compelling personal statements and supplemental essays.
Extracurriculars: Highlight meaningful involvement and leadership roles.
Letters of Recommendation: Request strong endorsements from teachers or mentors.
Demonstrated Interest: Engage with colleges through visits, virtual events, or communication with admissions offices.
Final Thoughts
While SAT and ACT scores are no longer a universal requirement, they still hold value in certain contexts. The key is to assess your strengths, research your target schools, and make a strategic decision about whether to submit your scores. No matter the path, a well-rounded application remains the most important factor in college admissions.
Tutoring & Test Prep
Want more personalized advice from our team? As part of our full-service approach to college advising, College Solutions offers tutoring and SAT/ACT prep as an add-on to our counseling packages for 10th, 11th, and 12th graders. In collaboration with our knowledgeable counselors, our expert tutors create personalized learning plans for math, English, and/or standardized testing prep that align with students’ goals for college admissions and beyond.